A Guide to Wine, Food & the Good Life
To subscribe and be notified anytime we post a new article, enter your email address in the box below, then click on Subscribe Now.

Food & Wine

Similar Articles:

  1. HAPPY THANKSGIVING 2017!
  2. RIDGE VINEYARDS - NEW RELEASES, A SPECIAL CHARITY EVENT FEATURING RIDGE WINES, & NOTES ON THREE GREAT OLD RIDGE WINES
  3. A VISIT TO DIAMOND CREEK VINEYARDS AND GREAT WINE AND FOOD
  4. 2016 THANKSGIVING POSTSCRIPT AND MORE!
  5. HAPPY THANKSGIVING 2016!
  6. PEOPLE AND WINE AGING TOGETHER
  7. SOME FAVORITE FOODS TO ACCOMPANY ROSÉS
  8. A GREAT WINE AND FOOD DINNER
  9. A GRAND WINE & FOOD DINNER IN VANCOUVER
  10. MOUNT EDEN VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON 41 YEAR RETROSPECTIVE
  11. VANCOUVER RARITIES DINNER FEBRUARY 3, 2015 FEATURING BURGUNDY
  12. AN APPRECIATION OF WOLFGANG PUCK
  13. RARE VINTAGE PORT TASTING 1927--1963, FEATURING QUINTA DO NOVAL NACIONAL
  14. A GRAND FOOD & WINE EVENT FEATURING OLD CALIFORNIA CABERNETS FROM INGLENOOK AND DIAMOND CREEK
  15. LEROY TASTING
  16. OLD RED BURGUNDIES PLUS A COUPLE OF ZINGERS AT TWO VERY DIFFERENT RESTAURANTS
  17. FOOD AND WINE SUGGESTIONS FOR YOUR THANKSGIVING MEAL
  18. DOMAINE COCHE-DURY & CORTON-CHARLEMAGNE: A MAGICAL COMBINATION
  19. THANKSGIVING 2013
  20. REMEMBERING ROUSSANNE
  21. A GREAT FOOD & WINE DINNER FEATURING KRUG CHAMPAGNE
  22. THANKSGIVING PAST 2012 & 2011
  23. THANKSGIVING - 2012
  24. ANDRÉ L. SIMON’S PARTNERS (1951) REVISITED
  25. UNFORGETTABLE
  26. WHAT’S BETTER THAN A CELEBRATION? TWO CELEBRATIONS!
  27. FATHER’S DAY: ROSÉ AND SALMON & DAISY ON THE WALL!
  28. A UNIQUE ADVENTURE: TEN COUNTRIES IN EIGHTEEN DAYS VIA CAR, PLANE, TRAIN, AND BOAT
  29. THE DUCK STOPS HERE
  30. 2010 SANCERRES AND SOME FOOD SUGGESTIONS
  31. THANKSGIVING PAST - 2011
  32. THANKSGIVING - 2011
  33. CHEF ROBERTO CREATES A NEW DINING EXPERIENCE
  34. MORE 2010 FRENCH ROSÉS WITH FOOD PAIRINGS
  35. Food by Roberto Cortez - Wine by The Underground
  36. Don’t Miss The 27th Annual Central Coast Wine Classic – Four Event-filled Days In July Celebrating The Wines, Cuisine, Music, Art And Lifestyle Of California’s Central Coast
  37. An Accidental Thanksgiving Discovery
  38. Are You Ready For Something Different?
  39. Richard Wing – One of a Kind
  40. A Dinner To Remember At Hatfield’s
  41. A Mediterranean Cruise For Wine Lovers
  42. Uncorking My Favorite Summertime Sippers
  43. Enjoy Summertime’s Sippable Sherries
  44. What To Serve With Rosé
  45. Barbecuing and Entertaining Wine Choices
  46. A Grand Experience on Michigan’s Famous Mackinac Island
  47. Central Coast Wine Classic Dinner
  48. Mélisse Restaurant -- A Great Dining Experience
  49. The Fontainebleau Hotel’s Hakkasan Restaurant in Miami Beach & The World’s Most Unusual Wine List?
  50. Movies, Wine, Food and Drink
  51. Confessions of An Addict
  52. Ridge Vineyards Monte Bello Retrospective Dinner

PEOPLE AND WINE AGING TOGETHER

John Tilson • 7/22/16        Print This Post Print This PostComment Bookmark and Share

1926 calon segur

What is the correlation?  Well, the fact is that people have varying life spans as do wines. Most people understand their aging process, but very few people understand the aging process of wines. In reality, most people could care less about how wines age. This creates a tremendous opportunity for those of us who love wines and understand their aging process. But, the fact is that only a small percentage of all the wine made throughout the world has an ability to improve with age. However, those wines that do improve with age are the most extraordinary wines in the world. For me, the best are some old California Cabernets, Red Burgundies, Red Bordeaux, and a few Red Spanish wines. Also, to a lesser extent, I would include White Burgundy, Champagne, Sauternes, and some late harvest German Rieslings.  Of course this is not a comprehensive list and there are others, but these are the wines where I have had the most experience with great old wines.

And, once you spend all the time, effort, and money in buying wines to cellar for long term aging, then the question becomes when to drink them?  For me this is a large part of the challenge and reward of aging wines. One of my favorite ways to drink old wines is to match the age of wines with anniversaries and birthdays. This can be done in two ways. The first is to match the year the wine was made with the year of the birthday or anniversary. For my wife and me, that is 1944 and 1967. The other is to match the year the wine was made with the person’s age or the anniversary year.  For us, this year, that would be 1972 and 1949. And, in the case of the latter match up, this changes each year and does not always work too well. But, it is something to fall back on if your birthday or anniversary happens to be from a not so good vintage year.

90th birthday

Recently my beloved mother-in-law, Bette, had her 90th birthday. Over the years we have had several wines celebrating her birthday. And this year my family and I celebrated her birthday with 2 bottles of 1990 and 1 bottle of 1926. This year both Bette’s birth year and her age were in sync with some really good wines. For the celebration, we chose a steak house in her home town of Fresno, CA.  The steakhouse is Flemings, which is a national chain. We have had other celebrations here as well and the food and service at this Flemings in Fresno has been consistently excellent. We started with appetizers followed by perfectly prepared prime steaks (for me, my favorite, rare bone in rib eye) with several side dishes. Here is the line-up of wines I chose from our cellar:

90 Pol Roger1990 Pol Roger Brut Champagne

1990 Monte Bello1990 Ridge Vineyards Monte Bello

1926 calon segur birthday1926 Calon Segur

All were excellent. The 1990 Pol Roger was rich and full, with great flavors and at a peak of perfection. The 1990 Ridge Monte Bello was a real tour-de-force. It was rich, intense, and complex with great balance. And, although absolutely delicious now, the wine will certainly enjoy a very long life ahead. But, the real story was the 1926 Château Calon Ségur. Château Calon Ségur is a third growth Bordeaux from Saint-Estèphe. The old Calon Ségurs have been consistently great for all the years I have been drinking wine. Here I am talking about the 1926, 1928, 1929, 1937, 1945, 1947, and 1949. All of these wines can be included in the top wines from these vintages and they can still be remarkable today.

Speaking of the 1926 Bordeaux vintage, it is in the shadow of the 1928 and 1929 vintages. The 1929s were for sure some of the best wines of the 20th century, but are chancy now. The 1928s share the same distinction with the difference being that the 1928s took a very long time to come around. But when they did, there were some really remarkable wines that held up beautifully. These include the 1928 Château Calon Ségur. I have both the 1928 and 1929 Calon Ségur still in my cellar and have had great bottles in recent years.

Although not as well known, the 1926 Bordeaux vintage has also produced great wines that can be still great today.  A 1926 Lafite Rothschild served a number of years ago at another of Bette’s birthdays was simply fabulous, and I still have another bottle. The 1926 Calon Ségur has also been a great bottle. But with really old wines you never know for sure until you pull the cork. All of my really old Bordeaux’s were purchased many years ago and mostly in the 1970s from England. I have consumed countless bottles that have been memorable. This 1926 Calon Ségur was a bottle with a high-shoulder fill. Today many American collectors regard this as a bad sign. But, that is not necessarily so. More important than the fill is the provenance and storage (to read about this click here). Also, if the provenance and storage are perfect, the bottles are likely to be in great condition even if the fills are far below the neck (to read an amazing story on this subject click here).

So armed with this information, I pulled the cork on the 1926 Calon Ségur as we were finishing our Champagne. Most of the cork came out intact, but there was about ¼ of the cork that broke into pieces. I was able to get most of the pieces out, and I poured the wine through a strainer into a glass. The color was deep, with a light orange amber tone and amber at the edge. It had a cedary perfume and very nice complex flavors with the fruit still very much in evidence. We all smelled and tasted the wine, and I poured the wine directly into all the glasses through the strainer. Our food arrived, and we began to enjoy the wine. But I had also opened the 1990 Ridge Monte Bello and decided to taste it. It was at a peak of perfection, so I decided to pour it into our glasses and told everyone to save some of the 1926 Calon Ségur until after the 1990 Ridge Monte Bello was mostly gone. This was based on the fact that the Calon Ségur was holding up nicely in the glass and was showing signs of improvement. With old wines sometimes they are bad when opened, and sometimes they are good or great. If they are good, sometimes they will improve with some air, and sometimes they will deteriorate. In the case of this 1926, the evolution was simply amazing. After nearly an hour in the glass, the wine really blossomed. The perfume was intense with a decided rose petal quality and hints of cedar and spice. On the palate the wine was like silk and very complex with lovely fruit accented by cedar and a distinct exotic floral quality. And the length was amazing. In short, this 1926 Calon Ségur was an absolutely phenomenal wine that I will always remember.

People and wine aging together – this is the story.  I hope all of you who have never had this type of experience will find a way to make it happen soon. For me, my family, and many of my friends, this is certainly one of life’s greatest pleasures.

In Vino Veritas,Sig

John Tilson

 

Post a Comment

4 comments for “PEOPLE AND WINE AGING TOGETHER”

  1. I couldn’t agree more about aging and when to drink. My wife and I were born in ’55, married in ’80, son (’89), daughter (’90), daughter in law (’88) and first grandson (’15). Last year for my wife’s mother’s 90th bday we drank a 1925 Marques de Murrieta Rioja Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial and it was magnificent!

    Posted by Jamie Garard | July 23, 2016, 7:01 am
  2. Wonderful story, warm, human, intimate, informative, such a pleasure to read. Thanks for sending us that joie de vrie!
    Birthday celebrations should continue to be fun in your 70’s, with perhaps a 1974 Mount Eden or Heitz Martha’s for your 74th, a 1975 Caymus Special Selection for your 75th, perhaps a 1976 B.V. Private Reserve for the 76th and a 1978 Volcanic Hill from Diamond Creek for your 78th.
    I think your 80’s will be real good too, with a 1982 Mouton Rothschild for you 82nd, a 1984 Lake from Diamond Creek for your 84th, a 1986 Lafite Rothschild at 86, and a 1987 Dominus on your 87th. The 90’s could bring a 1991 Ridge Monte Bello, for your 92nd a Maya from Dalla Valle, and on it goes. 1944 is also my birth year, so I’m thinking about this too.
    And if it’s not too late, a 1949 Cheval Blanc to further celebrate your 49th Anniversary would be nice. If that’s a wine glass I see in front of wonderful Ms. Bette, I’ll bet she’ll drink to that too.
    Cheers,
    Bill

    Posted by Bill Tisch | July 23, 2016, 1:07 pm
  3. Thanks Jamie,
    You’ve got some good years to choose from. Interesting about the 1925 Marques de Murrieta Rioja Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial. I am not surprised that it was great. I still have a bottle of the 1925 Marques De Riscal. It too has been a magnificent wine in the past and I am sure it is great today.I am waiting for a special time to drink it. This is also one of the great pleasures of having old wine – deciding when to drink it!
    In Vino Veritas,
    John

    Posted by John Tilson | August 4, 2016, 10:21 am
  4. Thanks Bill for the kind words.
    I like your choices. I also have a bottle each of 1944 Romanee-Conti, 1944 d’Yquem, and 1944 Inglenook. Very little great in our birth year, but these wines have all been great in the past. Our anniversary is coming up and we will drink another 1967 Petrus. This is a very great wine in a mediocre year with only a few others like La Mission Haut Brion, Latour, d’Yquem and a few other Sauternes. Then as you say we have the 70s and 80s to look forward to with a lot of great wines. So here’s to the future!
    In Vino Veritas,
    John

    Posted by John Tilson | August 4, 2016, 10:46 am

Post a Comment